Treatment

Because BPH rarely causes serious complications, men usually have a choice between treating it or opting for watchful waiting:

• Watchful Waiting. Watchful waiting involves lifestyle changes and an annual examination. Even when choosing watchful waiting, an initial examination is critical to rule out other disorders.
• Treatment Options. The primary goals of treatment for BPH are to improve urinary flow and to reduce symptoms. Many options are available. They include drug therapies, minimally invasive procedures, and major surgery.

Choosing Between Treatment and Watchful Waiting

The choice between watchful waiting and treatment usually depends on a number of factors, such as urine flow rates, prostate size, and PSA levels. Men with BPH who develop symptoms at around age 50 are more likely to need treatment within their lifetimes than older men. Unfortunately, there is no way at present to determine who specifically might be at risk for serious problems and need early treatment.

The development of the International Prostate Symptoms Score (IPSS) has made the evaluation of symptoms somewhat easier. This scoring service serves as a benchmark for determining severity. The decision to treat or not to treat is typically based on the guidelines described below, but the ultimate choice is often guided primarily by a man's perception of his own symptoms.

Mild or No Symptoms. Men with mild or no symptoms (IPSS scores of 7 or below) usually choose watchful waiting even if their prostates are enlarged. BPH eventually progresses to the point of needing treatment in about 15% of men with mild symptoms who wait.

Moderate Symptoms. The choice is most difficult for men with moderate symptoms (scores between 8 and 19) and may simply depend on a man's ability to tolerate them. Some studies have reported that up to 40% of men with moderate symptoms eventually seek treatment, and a quarter require surgery. In a small percentage of patients, symptoms improve.

Severe Symptoms. Men with severe symptoms (scores over 20) nearly always choose treatment, although if their prostate glands are small or normal-sized, symptoms may improve.

Deciding Between Surgery and Medication After Choosing Treatment

If a man opts for treatment, there are several choices. Most experts recommend a staged approach as follows:

• Mild Symptoms. Medications are the best choice for men with mild symptoms who decide to have their condition treated. There are two standard choices: alpha-blockers and anti-androgens, nearly always finasteride (Proscar). Specific conditions determine the choice, although most men take an alpha-blocker. Men with mild symptoms who choose surgery only experience minor improvement afterward but face the same risks as patients with more severe symptoms.
• Moderate to Severe Symptoms. Men with moderate to severe symptoms often respond to the same medications as men with mild symptoms. (Combinations of alpha-blockers and finasteride are under investigation.) Recent developments in drug therapy have reduced the number of surgical procedures needed and delayed their use. However, a quarter of men with moderate symptoms, and even more men with severe symptoms eventually need surgery. If a man chooses surgery, there are many choices. Transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP) is the standard procedure, but less invasive procedures, particularly those using heat or lasers to destroy prostate tissue, are gaining prominence.

Click the icon to see an illustrated series detailing transurethral resection of the prostate surgery.

The most common reason for choosing surgery is obstruction of the bladder outlet, which causes urinary retention. Surgery is also typically a reasonable option when BPH is clearly related to one or more of the following conditions:

• Recurrent urinary tract infection.
• Hematuria (blood in the urine). Studies have suggested that left untreated, two-thirds of patients continue to bleed and one third require surgery. The drug finasteride may help some men with this condition and should probably be tried before surgery.
• Bladder stones.
• Kidney problems.
• Some experts believe that surgery might benefit patients for whom an early diagnosis of prostate cancer is important. Unsuspected prostate cancer is detected during surgery in about 15% of cases.

The greatest improvements resulting from surgery are usually increased urinary flow and reduced urine retention. In one study, men who chose surgery reported more worry and depression before the procedure, but afterward they had less depression and anxiety than those who had chosen medication. Often, however, the benefits of surgery are not permanent.