Random Article
Braces
A brace can prevent further progression of moderate curves of (24 to 40 degrees). However, a brace will almost never reverse an existing curve and is only used to stop progression. One study reported overall success rates of around 74%, but results vary widely depending on the length of time the brace is worn, the type of brace, and the severity of the curve. The great majority of subjects in scoliosis studies are girls. Limited data suggest that in boys compliance rates are low, and braces are not effective.
Compliance with wearing a brace correlates strongly with success rate. In analysis of 34 patients, the compliance rate for the patients whose curve progressed by more than 5 degrees was 62%, while the compliance rate for the patients who did not progress was 85%.
In overweight patients with adolescent idiopathic scoliosis, braces appear to be less effective than in those who are not overweight. In one 10-year multicenter retrospective study, overweight patients were about three times more likely to have an unsuccessful result with braces than were people of normal weight.
Many experts have questioned whether a brace is any better than nature in halting curvature progress. Early studies found that braces were successful in halting progression in only half of cases (the same rate as no treatment at all). In recent years, however, braces have improved. Many now fit under the arms and can be worn under clothing, so that patients are much more likely to use them for longer periods during the day, which greatly affects their success rates.
Team Approach
Wearing the brace for the prescribed time is difficult but essential for any success. A team approach, with several health professionals involved, is beneficial and often necessary to support the patient through the bracing process. An orthopedic surgeon interprets the x-rays, assesses the potential progression of the scoliosis, and plans the treatment with the patient and family. If a brace is used, an orthotist measures and fits the patient with the device. A physical therapist tailors an exercise program best suited for the patient. A nurse may also coordinate the treatment plans and provide physical and emotional support.
Types of Braces
Milwaukee Brace. A full torso brace called the Milwaukee brace was the standard treatment until a decade ago. It is still used particularly for high curves.
The device contains a wide flat bar in front and two smaller ones in back. These bars attach to a ring around the neck that has rests for the chin and back of the head. One study determined that correcting the curve occurs best if the patient lays on their chest when wearing the brace. Some researchers suggest that increasing the tension on the chest straps might add benefit. The brace is also periodically adjusted for growth.
The brace needs to be worn 23 hours a day, with relief during bathing and exercise only. Compliance is a major problem. In one study, only 15% of patients wore the Milwaukee brace as directed. It is a particularly difficult brace to endure wearing; one woman who had worn it for 7 years during adolescence remembered being invisible during her school years, ignored and shunned by other children.
The Boston and TLSO Braces. Molded braces called thoracolumbar-sacral orthoses (TLSOs), most often the Boston brace, come up to beneath the underarms and can be fitted close to the skin so they do not show beneath clothing. It appears to be effective for mid-back and lower curves. In one study, treatment was judged successful in 61% of adolescents who wore Boston braces, and success correlated with wearing the brace more than 18 hours a day. Wearing the brace for 16 hours a day may still be beneficial, although the risk for curve progression is significantly higher the less time the brace is worn. These braces have problems; they are hot, reduce lung capacity by nearly 20%, and cause mild, temporary changes in kidney function.
The Charleston Bending Brace. The Charleston Bending Brace is worn only at night. Some doctors question its value, although it appears to be suitable for small, flexible curves. In a 2002 study, it was equally effective as the Boston brace. Other studies have reported success rates of 56 - 66% in patients who wore the brace as directed. Still, more than 10% of the patients using either brace eventually needed surgery.
Additional Braces in Development. New braces are being developed in an attempt to improve compliance and results. Some examples are:
- The Providence brace is a computer-fitted device that is worn only at night. It is specifically designed for the individual curvature abnormalities, and early studies are showing promise.
- A bracing method called the SpineCor uses adjustable bands and a cotton vest that allows flexibility. A 2003 study reported that after 2 years, the brace corrected the curve by 5 degrees in more than half the patients, while 38% were stabilized and only 7% had curvature that worsened by more than 5 degrees. A recent trial of 24 girls with idiopathic scoliosis compared the SpineCor with a TLSO-type brace. The study indicated that the SpineCor did not halt curvature progression associated with idiopathic scoliosis during the pubertal growth spurt whereas the TLSO device did.
- The custom-fitted TriaC brace exerts pressure in specific areas of the back to allow greater comfort and flexibility. It may be less conspicuous than some of the older braces.
Studies are needed to determine if these or other new braces provide any additional value.
Braces and Quality of Life
According to a 2003 study, compliance in wearing the brace averages 65% (although it varied from 8 - 90%). Patients were apt to wear them at night but often wore them sporadically during the day. The quality of life can vary by the type of brace worn. In one study, patients who had the Milwaukee brace reported greater impairment than patients with the Boston, TSLO, or Charleston braces. The choice of brace should be one that will be the most effective for a particular patient with the lowest impact on quality of life. Young people often refuse to wear braces, even the newer models, and emotional support from the family and professionals is extremely important to help a child accept the process and sustain compliance. On a positive note, one study reported that brace treatment did not negatively affect the self images of the adolescents who had to wear them.
Exercise and Physical Therapy While Wearing Braces
For children who require braces, an exercise program helps boost well being, improves compliance with treatment, and keeps muscles in tone so that the transition period after brace removal is easier.
An exercise and physical therapy program is important to maintain or achieve the following:
- Chest mobility.
- Proper breathing. In one study, young girls who wore the Boston brace and performed aerobic exercises for 30 minutes four times a week experienced improved lung function, whereas lung function declined in girls who did not exercise.
- Muscle strength (especially in the abdominal muscles).
- Flexibility in the spine. One small study showed that patients who performed exercises improving flexibility in the torso experienced less spinal twisting and had improved curvature.
- Correct posture. Practicing correct posture, especially in front of a mirror, is an extremely important part of any physical therapy program. A patient who is accustomed to a curved spine may have the sensation of being crooked when first taught to properly align the spine. Practicing in front of a mirror provides a reality check.
- Patients must also learn to conduct daily activities while wearing the brace. Patients tend to comply with physical therapy in the period when the brace is first being used. They typically stop exercising when they have gotten used to the brace, however, and resume exercising only near the time the brace is being removed. Patients who don't stay with the program throughout the duration of brace use experience a weakening in the back at the time of removal.
